Until today, I thought the phrase “diamond in the rough” meant finding something valuable (the “diamond”) amidst a larger collection of valueless stuff (“the rough”). Like, a diamond in a field of pebbles or something. But I’m paranoid, so I googled the phrase to make sure I wasn’t misusing it, and learned “the rough” is actually just referring to the diamond being uncut.
That anecdote has nothing to do with the book except that I was planning to open this review by saying “The ratio of diamonds to rough in this book is less than optimal”, and I decided it would be easier to explain to you that I now recognize the stupidity of that opening line than it would be to come up with a new one.
Anyway, this collection has a lot of stories. Some are great, some are mediocre, some are insufferable. I won’t name the insufferable ones because the author of at least one of them is still alive, and my conscience allows me to speak ill of only the dead (in public, at least). So let’s focus on the good.
The most memorable story for me is Michael Moorcock’s “Pale Roses”. It’s a distant-future story exploring the alien values that might arise in a society without scarcity or challenges. The protagonist, Werther, is a misfit who romanticizes the precarious lives humans lived in the distant past, and is exhilarated by the opportunity to meet a holdover from that era. (I enjoyed Werther’s misguided attempts to recreate artifacts from our time, such as “a toy fish-tank (capable of firing real fish)”1.) Ultimately we learn this is a ruse created by Werther’s friend as a gift to him—the gift being the opportunity to experience what sin and guilt are like.
Barrington J. Bayley’s “Life Trap” follows monks who are investigating what happens to a person after death. The story’s opening paragraph foreshadows that they won’t like what they find:
…all seekers after hidden knowledge run the risk of finding that ignorance was after all the happier state.2
And it is indeed a creatively terrifying revelation: that when you die, you experience your life in reverse, and then forward again from birth, back and forth, forever.
Peter Crowther’s “Palindromic” deals with a small town’s reaction to aliens who appear suddenly and behave in a mystifying, indifferent manner. It turns out that the aliens were moving through time in the opposite direction of us.
Nalo Hopkinson’s “Message in a Bottle” is a tale of strangely precocious children who are in fact time travelers—bioengineered to be small in order to cut down on the cost of sending them backward. And bioengineered to be long-lived so the future won’t have to pay the cost of retrieving them with a time machine. They’re searching for the shell of a mollusc which they consider to be an influential artist.
There are two fun stories from Kage Baker’s “Company” universe, which reminds me a bit of Connie Willis’s Oxford Time Travel series.
Some other interesting ideas that come up: